Investors Press Releases Press Releases Details

Press Releases Details

View all news

WellChoice, Inc. Reports Third Quarter 2004 Results

October 27, 2004
  • Third quarter 2004 net income of $61.9 million, or $0.74 per diluted share, $0.01 over guidance and $0.02 above the Thomson/First Call Mean
  • Commercial managed care membership, excluding NYC and NYS PPO, increased by 238,000 members, or 10.3%, to 2,539,000 since year-end 2003
  • Commercial managed care membership, excluding NYC and NYS PPO, increased sequentially by 60,000 members, or 2.4%, for the third quarter 2004
  • Total corporate membership increased by 177,000 members, or 3.7%, to 4,931,000 since year-end 2003
  • Full-year 2004 earnings guidance raised to a range of $2.93 to $2.96 per diluted share, from a range of $2.90 to $2.94
  • Full-year 2005 earnings are expected to be in the range of $3.35 to $3.41 per diluted share based on 84.3 million average shares outstanding
  • NEW YORK--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Oct. 27, 2004--WellChoice, Inc. (NYSE:WC) WellChoice, Inc. (NYSE:WC) today reported results for the quarter ended September 30, 2004.

    WellChoice reported net income for the third quarter 2004 of $61.9 million, or $0.74 per diluted share, and for the nine months ended September 30, 2004, of $186.6 million, or $2.23 per diluted share. The third quarter results exceed both the company's guidance range and analyst expectations.

    "We are pleased with our financial performance this quarter which was driven by significant growth in our core managed care products as well as by our continued focus on controlling administrative expenses," said Michael A. Stocker, M.D., President and Chief Executive Officer of WellChoice. "We expect to add over 100,000 new national account members as of January 2005 and we are confident that our new consumer directed product and our innovative 360(degree) Health services program will allow us to maintain and expand our leadership position in all of our markets."

    "Our third quarter 2004 results exceeded our expectations due to good enrollment growth and strong underwriting margins," said John W. Remshard, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of WellChoice. "Our third quarter performance is in line with our 2004 financial goals, and puts us on a path to achieve our growth expectations for 2005."

    Compared to December 31, 2003, enrollment in the Commercial Managed Care segment, excluding New York State and New York City PPO membership, increased by 10.3% as of September 30, 2004. Membership in the entire Commercial Managed Care segment increased by 6.1% to 4,355,000 since December 31, 2003. Membership in the Other Insurance Products and Services segment, which includes indemnity and individual products, declined by 11.1% since December 31, 2003. Total membership at September 30, 2004, was 4,931,000, an increase of 3.7% since December 31, 2003. Self-funded membership grew 11.9% since December 31, 2003, to 1,942,000 as of September 30, 2004, and now accounts for 39.4% of overall membership, an increase of 290 basis points over the prior year-end.

    Total revenues for the nine months ended September 30, 2004, were $4.34 billion compared to $4.01 billion for the nine months ended September 30, 2003. Administrative service fees increased $37.2 million to $373.5 million. Insured premiums were $3.9 billion for the nine months ended September 30, 2004, compared to $3.6 billion in the nine months of last year. The overall medical loss ratio was 86.1% in the nine months ended September 30, 2004, an 80 basis point increase compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2003. Compared to the nine months ended September 30, 2003, administrative expenses increased by $16.1 million to $676.7 million in the nine months ended September 30, 2004.

    Total revenues for the third quarter 2004 were $1.45 billion compared to $1.34 billion for the third quarter last year. Insured premiums were $1.31 billion compared to $1.21 billion in the third quarter last year. Administrative service fees increased $14.6 million to $128.4 million. The overall medical loss ratio was 86.0% in the third quarter 2004, a 160 basis point increase compared to the third quarter last year. Administrative expenses decreased by $2.9 million to $228.6 million in the third quarter 2004 compared to the prior year third quarter.

    Cash flow from operating activities was $214.0 million for the nine months ended September 30, 2004. The Company experienced net positive prior period reserve development of $1.2 million for the third quarter 2004 for its prospectively rated business. Days claims payable was 55.9 days as of the third quarter 2004.

    EARNINGS OUTLOOK

    WellChoice is raising its earnings guidance for 2004 from a range of $2.90 to $2.94 to a range of $2.93 to $2.96 per diluted share based on 83.9 million weighted average shares outstanding. In addition, the company is reconfirming its 2004 guidance for core commercial managed care membership growth in the range of 9% to 11% and total corporate membership growth in the range of 3% to 4%.

    For the full year 2005 we expect earnings to be in the range of $3.35 to $3.41 per diluted share based on 84.3 million average shares outstanding.

    About WellChoice

    WellChoice, Inc. is the parent company of the largest health insurer in the State of New York based on PPO and HMO membership. WellChoice, through its Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield subsidiaries, has the exclusive right to use the Blue Cross and Blue Shield names and marks in 10 downstate New York counties and one or both of these names and marks in selected counties in upstate New York. WellChoice offers a broad portfolio of products, including managed care and traditional indemnity products, and has a broad customer base including large group, middle-market and small group, individual, and national accounts. Additional information on WellChoice can be found at www.wellchoice.com.

    Conference Call and Webcast

    The Company will host a conference call and webcast today at 5:30 PM (EST) to review these results, as well as to discuss the outlook for 2004 and 2005. The conference call can be accessed domestically by dialing 1-800-784-3697. International participants dial 1-706-643-1656. Please ask for reference number 211144, 10 minutes prior to the start of the call. An audio replay of the call will be available for seven days following the conference call. To access the replay, please dial 1-800-642-1687 and enter reference number 211144. International callers can access the replay by dialing 1-706-645-9291 and enter reference number 211144.

    Investors, analysts and the general public are also invited to listen to the conference call over the Internet by visiting WellChoice's web site at www.wellchoice.com. Financial, statistical and other information related to the conference call will also be available on the site.

    Cautionary Statement

    Some of the information contained in this press release is forward-looking, including statements relating to future financial or business results. Forward-looking information is based on management's estimates, assumptions and projections and is subject to significant uncertainties and other factors, many of which are beyond the company's control. Important risk factors could cause future results to differ materially from those estimated by management. Those risks and uncertainties include but are not limited to: our ability to accurately predict health care costs and to manage those costs through underwriting criteria, quality initiatives and medical management; product design and negotiation of favorable provider reimbursement rates; our ability to maintain or increase our premium rates; possible reductions in enrollment in our health insurance programs or changes in membership; the regional concentration of our business in the New York metropolitan area and the effects of economic downturns in that region or generally; future bio-terrorist activity or other potential public health epidemics; the impact of health care reform and other regulatory matters; the outcome of litigation; and the potential loss of our New York City account. For a more detailed discussion of these and other important factors that may materially affect WellChoice, please see the company's filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission, including the discussion of risk factors and historical results of operations and financial condition in its Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2003, as amended, its Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the period ended March 31, 2004, as amended, its Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the period ended June 30, 2004, and its Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q for the period ended September 30, 2004 to be filed with the Commission this afternoon.

    EXHIBIT A
    
                               WellChoice, Inc.
                                  Membership
    
                             September 30,         June 30,   December 31,
    (In thousands)         2004         2003         2004         2003
                       ---------------------------------------------------
    Products and services:
    ---------------------
     Commercial
      managed care:
       Group PPO, HMO,
        EPO and other(1)(2)  2,539        2,278        2,479        2,301
       New York City
        and New York
        State PPO            1,816        1,802        1,815        1,805
                       ------------ ------------ ------------ ------------
       Total commercial
        managed care         4,355        4,080        4,294        4,106
     Other insurance
      products and services:
       Indemnity               365          498          373          428
       Individual              211          222          213          220
                       ------------ ------------ ------------ ------------
       Total other
        insurance
        products and
        services               576          720          586          648
       Overall total         4,931        4,800        4,880        4,754
                       ============ ============ ============ ============
    Customers:
    ------------------
       Large group           2,975        2,927        2,945        2,931
       Small group and
        middle market          463          433          455          444
       Individuals             266          273          266          269
       National
        accounts             1,227        1,167        1,214        1,110
                       ------------ ------------ ------------ ------------
       Overall total         4,931        4,800        4,880        4,754
                       ============ ============ ============ ============
    Funding type:
    ------------------
     Commercial
      managed care:
       Insured               2,659        2,595        2,644        2,620
       Self-funded           1,696        1,485        1,650        1,486
                       ------------ ------------ ------------ ------------
       Total commercial
        managed care         4,355        4,080        4,294        4,106
                       ============ ============ ============ ============
     Other insurance
      products and services:
       Insured                 330          420          335          398
       Self-funded             246          300          251          250
                       ------------ ------------ ------------ ------------
       Total other insurance
        products and
        services               576          720          586          648
                       ------------ ------------ ------------ ------------
       Overall total         4,931        4,800        4,880        4,754
                       ============ ============ ============ ============
    
    (1) Our HMO product includes Medicare+Choice. As of September 30,
        2004, September 30 2003, June 30, 2004 and December 31, 2003, we
        had approximately 56,000 members, 51,000 members, 54,000 members
        and 50,000 members, respectively, enrolled in Medicare+Choice.
    (2) "Other" consists of point of service (POS) members and our members
        enrolled in dental only coverage.
    
    EXHIBIT B
    
                               WellChoice, Inc.
                       Consolidated Statements of Income
    
                                                    Three Months Ended
                                                       September 30,
                                                     2004         2003
                                                 ------------ ------------
    ($ in millions, except share and per share
     data)
    Revenue:
        Premiums earned                          $   1,305.9  $   1,209.3
        Administrative service fees                    128.4        113.8
        Investment income, net                          16.7         16.7
        Other income (expense), net                        -         (0.5)
                                                 ------------ ------------
    Total revenue                                    1,451.0      1,339.3
    
    Expenses:
        Cost of benefits provided                    1,122.6      1,020.3
        Administrative expenses                        228.6        231.5
                                                 ------------ ------------
    Total expenses                                   1,351.2      1,251.8
    Income before income taxes                          99.8         87.5
    Income tax expense                                  37.9         35.4
                                                 ------------ ------------
    Net income                                   $      61.9  $      52.1
                                                 ============ ============
    Basic and diluted earnings per common share  $      0.74  $      0.62
    Shares used to compute basic earnings
     per common share, based on weighted
     average shares outstanding                   83,559,141   83,490,478
    Shares used to compute diluted earnings per
     common share based on weighted average
     shares outstanding                           83,908,346   83,490,478
    Additional data:
    ---------------
    Medical loss ratio (1)                              86.0%        84.4%
    Administrative expense ratio (2)                    15.9%        17.5%
    
    (1) Medical loss ratio represents cost of benefits provided as a
        percentage of premiums earned.
    
    (2) Administrative expense ratio represents administrative expense as
        a percentage of premiums earned and administrative service fees.
        As presented, our administrative expense ratio does not take into
        account a significant portion of our activity generated by
        self-funded, or ASO, business, which, at September 30, 2004,
        represented approximately 39.4% of total membership. Therefore, in
        the following table, we provide the information needed to
        calculate the administrative expense ratio on a "premium
        equivalent" basis because that ratio measures administrative
        expenses relative to the entire volume of insured and self-funded
        business serviced by us and is commonly used in the health
        insurance industry to compare operating efficiency among
        companies. Administrative expense ratio on a premium equivalent
        basis is calculated by dividing administrative expenses by
        "premium equivalents" for the relevant periods. Premium
        equivalents is the sum of premium earned, administrative service
        fees and the amount of paid claims attributable to our self-funded
        business pursuant to which we provide a range of customer
        services, including claims administration, billing and membership
        services. Claims paid for our self-funded health business is not
        our revenue. The premium equivalents for the years indicated were
        as follows:
    
    Premium Equivalents Table:
                                                    Three Months Ended
                                                       September 30,
                                                     2004         2003
                                                 ------------ ------------
    Revenue:
    Premiums earned                              $   1,305.9  $   1,209.3
    Administrative service fees                        128.4        113.8
    Claims paid for our self-funded health
     business                                          971.1        775.9
                                                 ------------ ------------
    
    Premium equivalents                          $   2,405.4  $   2,099.0
                                                 ============ ============
    
    
    EXHIBIT C
    
                               WellChoice, Inc.
                       Consolidated Statements of Income
    
                                                     Nine Months Ended
                                                        September 30,
                                                      2004        2003
                                                 ------------ ------------
    ($ in millions, except share
     and per share data)
    Revenue:
        Premiums earned                          $   3,915.1  $   3,622.9
        Administrative service fees                    373.5        336.3
        Investment income, net                          50.8         45.9
        Other income, net                                0.2          0.8
                                                 ------------ ------------
    Total revenue                                    4,339.6      4,005.9
    
    Expenses:
        Cost of benefits provided                    3,371.7      3,089.4
        Administrative expenses                        676.7        660.6
                                                 ------------ ------------
    Total expenses                                   4,048.4      3,750.0
    Income before income taxes                         291.2        255.9
    Income tax expense                                 104.6        107.3
                                                 ------------ ------------
    Net income                                   $     186.6  $     148.6
                                                 ============ ============
    Basic and diluted earnings per common share  $      2.23  $      1.78
    Shares used to compute basic earnings per
     common share, based on weighted average
     shares outstanding                           83,514,673   83,490,478
    Shares used to compute diluted earnings per
     common
      share, based on weighted average shares
       outstanding                                83,832,419   83,490,478
    Additional data:
    ---------------
    Medical loss ratio (1)                              86.1%        85.3%
    Administrative expense ratio (2)                    15.8%        16.7%
    
    (1) Medical loss ratio represents cost of benefits provided as a
        percentage of premiums earned.
    
    (2) Administrative expense ratio represents administrative expense as
        a percentage of premiums earned and administrative service fees.
        As presented, our administrative expense ratio does not take into
        account a significant portion of our activity generated by
        self-funded, or ASO, business, which, at September 30, 2004,
        represented approximately 39.4% of total membership. Therefore, in
        the following table, we provide the information needed to
        calculate the administrative expense ratio on a "premium
        equivalent" basis because that ratio measures administrative
        expenses relative to the entire volume of insured and self-funded
        business serviced by us and is commonly used in the health
        insurance industry to compare operating efficiency among
        companies. Administrative expense ratio on a premium equivalent
        basis is calculated by dividing administrative expenses by
        "premium equivalents" for the relevant periods. Premium
        equivalents is the sum of premium earned, administrative service
        fees and the amount of paid claims attributable to our self-funded
        business pursuant to which we provide a range of customer
        services, including claims administration, billing and membership
        services. Claims paid for our self-funded health business is not
        our revenue. The premium equivalents for the years indicated were
        as follows:
    
    
    Premium Equivalents Table:
    
                                                     Nine Months Ended
                                                       September 30,
                                                     2004         2003
                                                 ------------ ------------
    Revenue:
    Premiums earned                              $   3,915.1  $   3,622.9
    Administrative service fees                        373.5        336.3
    Claims paid for our self-funded health
     business                                        2,683.6      2,153.8
                                                 ------------ ------------
    Premium equivalents                          $   6,972.2  $   6,113.0
    
    
    EXHIBIT D
    
                               WellChoice, Inc.
                          Consolidated Balance Sheets
    
    ($ in millions, except share                   Sept. 30,    Dec. 31,
     and per share data)                             2004         2003
                                                 ------------ ------------
    Assets
       Investments:
          Fixed maturities, at fair value
           (amortized cost: $1,289.2 and
           $1,036.7)                             $   1,287.1  $   1,037.2
          Marketable equity securities, at fair
           value (cost: $47.0 and $52.9)                48.6         60.4
          Short-term investments                       178.0        232.5
          Other long-term equity investments            32.9         31.7
                                                 ------------ ------------
       Total investments                             1,546.6      1,361.8
       Cash and cash equivalents                       696.9        697.5
                                                 ------------ ------------
       Total investments and cash and cash
        equivalents                                  2,243.5      2,059.3
       Receivables:
          Billed premiums, net                         106.5         92.4
          Accrued premiums                             315.5        285.8
          Other amounts due from customers, net        104.5        107.1
          Miscellaneous, net                            93.3         84.1
                                                 ------------ ------------
       Total receivables                               619.8        569.4
       Property, equipment and information
        systems, net                                   106.6        113.5
       Deferred taxes, net                             170.4        216.5
       Other                                            98.4         84.3
                                                 ------------ ------------
       Total assets                              $   3,238.7  $   3,043.0
                                                 ============ ============
    Liabilities and stockholders' equity
       Liabilities:
          Unpaid claims and claims adjustment
           expense                               $     681.6  $     609.5
          Unearned premium income                       98.3        134.2
          Accounts payable and accrued expenses         73.7        104.5
          Group and other contract liabilities         258.8        226.0
          Other                                        506.5        536.5
                                                 ------------ ------------
      Total liabilities                              1,618.9      1,610.7
    Stockholders' equity:
       Common stock, $0.01 per share value,
        225,000,000 shares
          Authorized; 2004-84,005,079, 2003-
           83,676,446 shares issued and                  0.8          0.8
          Outstanding
       Class B common stock, $0.01 per share
        value, one share
          authorized; one share issued and
           outstanding                                     -            -
       Preferred stock, $0.01 per share value,
        25,000,000 shares
          authorized; none issued and
           outstanding                                     -            -
       Additional paid-in capital                    1,273.6      1,262.2
       Retained earnings                               349.1        162.5
       Unearned restricted stock compensation          (12.6)        (6.0)
       Accumulated other comprehensive income            8.9         12.8
                                                 ------------ ------------
       Total stockholders' equity                    1,619.8      1,432.3
    Total liabilities and stockholders' equity   $   3,238.7  $   3,043.0
                                                 ============ ============
    
    EXHIBIT E
    
                               WellChoice, Inc.
                     Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows
    
                                                     Nine Months Ended
                                                       September 30,
                                                     2004         2003
                                                 ------------ ------------
    ($ in millions)
    Cash flows from operating activities:
      Net income                                 $     186.6  $     148.6
      Adjustments to reconcile net income to net
       cash provided by
           operating activities:
         Depreciation and amortization                  29.1         28.2
         Deferred income tax expense                    47.9         41.2
         Other                                         (22.7)        (8.8)
         Net change in assets and liabilities          (26.9)        18.8
                                                 ------------ ------------
      Net cash provided by operating activities        214.0        228.0
                                                 ------------ ------------
    
    Cash flows from investing activities:
      Purchases of property, equipment and
       information systems, net                        (25.1)       (41.3)
      Net purchases of available for sale
       investments                                    (186.3)       117.4
                                                 ------------ ------------
      Net cash (used in) provided by investing
       activities                                     (211.4)        76.1
                                                 ------------ ------------
    
    Cash flows from financing activities:
      Decrease in capital lease obligations             (3.2)         1.6
                                                 ------------ ------------
    Net cash (used in) provided by financing
     activities                                         (3.2)         1.6
                                                 ------------ ------------
    
    Net change in cash and cash equivalents             (0.6)       305.7
    Cash and cash equivalents at beginning of
     period                                            697.5        487.4
                                                 ------------ ------------
    Cash and cash equivalents at end of period   $     696.9  $     793.1
                                                 ============ ============
    Supplemental disclosure:
    Income taxes paid                            $      60.9  $      60.2
                                                 ============ ============
    
    EXHIBIT F
    
                               WellChoice, Inc.
                           Segment Operating Results
    
                                                    Three Months Ended
                                                       September 30,
                                                     2004         2003
                                                 ------------ ------------
    ($ in millions)
    Commercial Managed Care:
    Total revenue                                $   1,226.1  $   1,111.6
    Income before income taxes                          87.7         56.5
    Medical loss ratio (1):
      Commercial managed care total                     86.1%        86.6%
      Commercial managed care, excluding New
       York City and New York State PPO (2)             82.3%        83.0%
    Administrative expense ratio                        13.7%        15.0%
    
    Other Insurance Products and Services:
    Total revenue                                $     224.9  $     227.7
    Income before income taxes                          12.1         31.0
    Medical loss ratio (1)                              84.9%        71.9%
    Administrative expense ratio (3)                    28.2%        29.7%
    
    (1) Medical loss ratio represents cost of benefits provided as a
        percentage of premiums earned.
    (2) We present commercial managed care medical loss ratio, excluding
        New York City and New York State PPO, because these accounts
        differ from our standard PPO product in that they are
        hospital-only accounts which have lower premiums relative to claim
        expense than accounts with full medical and hospital coverage. The
        lower premiums and the size of these accounts distort our
        performance when the total medical loss ratio is presented.
    (3) Administrative expense ratio represents administrative expenses as
        a percentage of premiums earned and administrative service fees.
    
    EXHIBIT G
    
                               WellChoice, Inc.
                           Segment Operating Results
    
                                                     Nine Months Ended
                                                       September 30,
                                                     2004         2003
                                                 ------------ ------------
    ($ in millions, except earnings per share)
    Commercial Managed Care:
    Total revenue                                $   3,666.2  $   3,284.8
    Income before income taxes                         253.1        208.4
    Medical loss ratio (1):
      Commercial managed care total                     86.5%        86.1%
      Commercial managed care, excluding New York
       City and New York State PPO (2)                  82.7%        82.4%
    Administrative expense ratio                        13.4%        14.2%
    
    Other Insurance Products and Services:
    Total revenue                                $     673.4  $     721.1
    Income before income taxes                          38.1         47.5
    Medical loss ratio (1)                              83.7%        81.1%
    Administrative expense ratio (3)                    28.6%        28.0%
    
    (1) Medical loss ratio represents cost of benefits provided as a
        percentage of premiums earned.
    (2) We present commercial managed care medical loss ratio, excluding
        New York City and New York State PPO, because these accounts
        differ from our standard PPO product in that they are
        hospital-only accounts which have lower premiums relative to claim
        expense than accounts with full medical and hospital coverage. The
        lower premiums and the size of these accounts distort our
        performance when the total medical loss ratio is presented.
    (3) Administrative expense ratio represents administrative expenses as
        a percentage of premiums earned and administrative service fees.
    

    CONTACT: WellChoice, Inc.
    Investor/Media:
    Deborah Loeb Bohren, 212-476-3552

    SOURCE: WellChoice, Inc.

    Multimedia Files:

    View all news